Soul of Adoption

Parenting => General Parenting => Topic started by: Topaz on Jan 06, 2026, 08:09 PM

Title: Some secrets are better left buried forever: How a psychic finally unearthed....
Post by: Topaz on Jan 06, 2026, 08:09 PM
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/crime-desk/article-15439123/secrets-better-left-buried-missing-father-psychic-family-home.html

Some secrets are better left buried forever: How a psychic finally unearthed the body of a missing father-of-four deep under the family's home. But it was what happened next that truly tore them all apart...

By TOM LEONARD, US CORRESPONDENT

Published: 17:02, 6 January 2026 | Updated: 17:04, 6 January 2026

One day in 1961, father of four and Korean War veteran George Carroll went out to buy a packet of cigarettes. He never came home again.  Or so his wife Dorothy told their young children. As 'her word was gospel' in those days, they believed her explanation.  'Don't even think about him,' Dorothy assured them, later silencing their natural curiosities. 'He wasn't a good guy.'

However, decades later a series of astonishing events revealed the dark secret behind their father's disappearance.  In a new documentary, The Secrets We Bury, the truth behind George's vanishing, which wife Dorothy took to her grave when she died of cancer in 1998, is laid bare for the first time.  It's a mystery involving missing family members living only streets away, children who suspected that their new stepfather had killed their father, a psychic medium and a body buried deep under the basement of a family house.  Mike, Dorothy's son who still lives in the family home in Lake Grove village on New York's Long Island, is the focus of the documentary. Now 64, he is the youngest of four children with sisters Jean, 71, and Pat, 69, and brother Steve, 68.  'When my mother became sick, my dad was always on her mind,' Mike says. 'On her deathbed, I asked, "Can you tell me anything about that before you leave?"  My mother literally turned her head, winked at me, never said a word and then passed away.'

Their father's fate had long puzzled the children. It seemed odd that he'd left his wallet and car behind and hadn't cashed his final pay cheque. And it was suspicious that no police report about his disappearance was ever filed.  There were rumours that he'd returned to a girlfriend he had in Korea during the war there in the 1950s, or that he'd been murdered by the Mob but nothing concrete.  Mike was only eight months old when George vanished and barely remembered him. Curiously, his older siblings who did remember their dad could not recall any drama leading up to the actual moment he vanished.  'I know I was Daddy's girl,' says Mike's sister Jean. 'My dad was there and then all of a sudden my dad wasn't there.'

After George vanished, Dorothy swiftly remarried and the children had a stepfather, Richard Darress, a newspaper photographer who lived locally. The older children described the switch from one father to another as 'almost seamless'.  Although the children didn't like Richard, family life continued.  Curiously, when a young Mike then got a job delivering newspapers, one of his customers Mr Yagel appeared at the door of their family home with a box of old share certificates that had belonged to George Carroll. While Mike asked his mother how Mr Yagel had known his father, she never explained.  Life continued, Mike got married and had children with his wife Debbi and later, when his mother a gregarious 'frustrated actress' who put on comedy shows in her large garage was struggling financially, they moved into the family home to help her out. But there were signs that Dorothy had secrets. When Debbi and Mike divorced in 1995, Dorothy warned Debbi that 'something would happen' to her daughter-in-law if she tried to take the house away from her in the divorce settlement. Debbi is clear that she believed Dorothy was entirely serious. It seemed that this wasn't such a 'normal' family after all.  A family bombshell came a couple of years after Dorothy's death in 1998 when Mike, who worked as a respiratory therapist, was called at 3am one night to tend to a patient at the local hospital.  He was surprised to find that the patient had the same unusual last name, Yagel, as the older man who years earlier had delivered the box of his father's papers. He was even more shocked when the patient, on learning he was Mike Carroll, announced he was his uncle George's brother.  Mike realised he had been delivering newspapers for years to the older man, Mr Yagel Sr, without ever knowing he was his grandfather.  His newfound uncle explained that George had been digging up his house to add an extension when he disappeared. The Yagels had always suspected George's body might be under the family home because the timing of the building work matched so neatly with his vanishing.  They'd become estranged from Dorothy, who they believed was involved.  Mike wouldn't hear anything against his beloved mother, but his sister Jean took up the investigation. She decided to consult a medium a plan that other family members, who didn't believe in such things, dismissed. However, Mike accompanied her to a séance in 2010.  The medium spent an hour talking about other family matters until Mike distinctly unimpressed impatiently told her he only wanted to learn about his father.  'She goes, "Oh, when it comes to the "M" word, I normally don't say anything until you give me the permission to do it,'" he says in the documentary. 'I said, "What's the "M" word?'" She replied: "Murder."'

She told the siblings that their father had been killed and buried in the basement of the family home identifying the precise location, explaining that the spot lay under a 'target' on the wall.  Jean was puzzled by what she meant, but Mike remembered a target used to hang on the wall at which they'd fire pellet guns when he was little, although it had long been taken down. How did the medium know about such a specific detail about their family home, from 60 years ago?

Mike was impressed. When he asked who did it, she replied with 'Richard'.

They were in no doubt she meant their former stepfather, Richard Darress, but dreaded breaking the news to his son, Richard Jr, with whom they'd grown up.  The latter was also interviewed for the documentary. Asked about the theory that his father killed George, he says: 'Is it possible? Sure it is. Is it likely? Probably not.'

The others were more convinced. Jean even had a distinct memory of waking up one morning, around the age of seven before her father's disappearance, to find a man sleeping on the living room sofa.  She later learned he was her soon-to-be stepfather Richard Darress Sr.  Darress had just got out of prison for theft and after meeting in a bar her father had offered him a place to sleep in return for help with the building work on his home.  So did Darress Sr and Dorothy have an affair while he was dossing on the sofa?

Mike says 'it kind of makes sense'.

Meanwhile, only siblings Jean and Mike believed that there could be something under the basement. Mike started digging, using only hammers and chisels to break through the concrete.  His initial excavation in the spot identified by the medium proved fruitless. But after his two adult sons joined the dig, hiring a team with ground-penetrating radar equipment, they identified a new place to search, a 5ft-square area that had been disturbed.  After spending months digging a huge 8ft hole without finding anything, they discovered an underground cinderblock wall on the edge of the excavation area. Breaking through it, they found a cavity which turned out to be a vault for the old house's water pump.  Inside, they first found of piece of decomposed fabric which turned out to be clothing. Under it was a pelvis bone. Then as they scrabbled away at the earth, it was revealed to be part of a complete human skeleton. It was Halloween, October 2018 57 years after George Carroll had vanished. 'Everyone had said I was wrong,' says Mike.

After many years during which everyone believed he and Jean were unhinged and needed to simply accept their father deserted them, this was 'payday', he says.  Richard Darress Jr describes the discovery as 'probably the most emotional day of my life your whole body turns numb, you start reflecting on your entire life. Not just who did it was it my father? Was it my mother? but it was "Oh my God, my siblings what did they endure their entire lives."'

He rushed back from a business trip in Chicago to be with them, aware that they had little doubt that his father had killed theirs.  The family immediately called police who after establishing this was not a typical Halloween prank call arrived in force, while the media also descended on the quiet neighbourhood. Investigators confirmed that the victim was indeed George Carroll, who had died from blunt force trauma to the head.  Anxious not to upset Richard Jr and his own family, the Carrolls initially refused to be drawn into the media's speculations on who they believed to be the killer.  That suspect, Darress Sr, had died just three months earlier infuriatingly, before the family had been able to talk to him about George's fate.  Parroting what he says he was told by his paternal uncle, Richard Jr believes George had been abusive towards Dorothy and that Richard Sr had been 'defending her'.  He tells the documentary: 'I've heard stories about George Carroll. He wasn't the best husband. I've heard the term "heavy hands"'.

Richard Jr's half-siblings accepted there was some truth to this as their mother claimed George had been 'rough with her' with scars to prove it after possibly suffering post-traumatic stress in the Korean War.  But, crucially, did she conspire with Darress Sr to kill George?

Some of her family cling to the hope that she knew nothing about the killing, although the fact she never filed a missing persons report and kept her children away from George's family is certainly suspicious.  And yet there's another explanation in this labyrinthine story.  Darress Sr's stepchildren claim he sexually molested the girls in the family –ean and Pat and that even while George was still alive, Darress repeatedly exposed himself to the Carroll children.  Jean remembers Darress as an 'evil' and 'manipulative' sexual 'predator'.  Is it possible, asks Steve Carroll, Jean's other brother, that George was murdered after he confronted Darress in the house over his predilections?

He certainly believes so, although he adds that if this was the case why on earth did his mother allow such a monster to remain in her home?

So many questions and so few answers. It doesn't exactly help that all of the siblings have wildly divergent theories as to who did what and why.  George's children accept that they will never know for certain which of them if any is correct although they can at least find small consolation in the fact that their father didn't abandon them after all.
Title: Re: Some secrets are better left buried forever: How a psychic finally unearthed....
Post by: Chyna on Jan 12, 2026, 06:56 PM
So Sad and I don't understand why some people are so cruel.
Title: Re: Some secrets are better left buried forever: How a psychic finally unearthed....
Post by: Montravia on Jan 16, 2026, 05:55 PM
There are some seriously evil people out there.