https://www.dailymail.com/lifestyle/article-15817599/Philippa-Roberts-detransition-man-woman.html
I transitioned into a man then changed my mind. Now the trans 'cult' that groomed me into changing sex has hounded me out of TWO cities
Exclusive interview: Nick Wallis.
Philippa Roberts is telling me about the day she had her breasts removed. She was 19 years old. As she came round from the general anaesthetic, she remembers seeing her mother sitting in the corner of the room. 'My mum said, "Are you happy?" and I burst into tears.'
Philippa was not happy. She was exhausted and emotionally overwhelmed. 'I sobbed and sobbed.'
Her mother 'hung her head and didn't speak for the rest of the day. It was awful.'
Philippa's elective mastectomy took place at the private Spire hospital in Hull ten years ago this August. Her name then was Caspar. She had a beard, a muscly body and was injecting NHS-prescribed testosterone. Six years later, she had a disorientating thought. Philippa is a detransitioner. She has rejected her trans identity and presents as female once more. Now she wants to tell her story. We meet on a bright spring afternoon in a London pub. Philippa is wearing a smart coat and tartan scarf. Her blonde hair is long. It is hard to believe she would ever pass as male, but she did 'for years'. There can be permanent effects of taking testosterone over such a long period. Philippa speaks in a low register and has to shave every day, which she calls 'a sad reminder of a very silly mistake I made at a young age'.
Philippa is still just 29. She is one of thousands of young people in the UK who, over the past 15 years, have declared that they are trans. Trans can mean you identify as the opposite gender to your birth sex. It can also include non-binary people, who don't identify with any gender. Trans-rights campaigners see the explosion in trans and non-binary identities as progress, a sign that people are finally able to escape the male / female straitjackets imposed by society. Others, including Philippa, believe it is 'social contagion'. They argue girls and young women are susceptible to social trends, and trans is the latest. 'Women work in groups,' says Philippa.
'When you're together and see others especially women with higher status adopting certain behaviours, it's likely that those will be adopted by others. You're looking at something that seems to offer status, benefits. It's social currency.'
Philippa says she has seen this happen, as well as living it. 'I've had two housemates transition and I know it was because I was trans.'
Philippa is lively and chatty, an open book when it comes to talking about her own situation. But she is wary of what she reveals about her family and loved ones (especially their names), as she is worried for their safety. Philippa will tell me she grew up near Bournemouth. Her mother was a doctor from a middle-class background, her father a smart and athletic self-made man. Both are retired. Philippa has one younger sibling, but she won't give any more details than that. As a child, Philippa was given every opportunity to better herself but alludes to a feeling of 'not quite being good enough'. At school she excelled at tennis and squash, which she played to county level. When she hit puberty (late, around 14 or 15), she was 5ft 3in with size 36E breasts. 'Men would just drool. Everyone said I looked like a porn star.'
Philippa felt vulnerable and started spending time in the gym, building her physique. In sixth form, she came out as a lesbian. Her friends weren't surprised. She remembers her mother saying, 'Do you want me to tell your father?'
Once he knew, it became clear the matter would not be discussed any further. Philippa learned more about her sexuality by watching LGBTQ+ YouTube, discovering the concept of being trans. 'Some gay women were talking about friends who had transitioned.'
She watched videos featuring trans people. 'I thought, ''I've never seen this before.'' I felt I should educate myself about it.'
Philippa passed her A-levels and in autumn 2014 started at Royal Holloway, University of London. She didn't adjust to life on campus. 'I struggled. I was not prepared for the partying and the boys.'
Her figure attracted unwelcome attention. 'I'd have these boys all trying to touch me. I'm like, "No. I don't like men. I'm a lesbian."
But they wouldn't stop. She talks of being groped. 'I was always on edge, thinking I was going to get raped.'
A trans neighbour offered to lend Philippa breast-binders. She declined but wore sports bras to make her chest less noticeable. She cut her hair short and thought by losing weight she could make her chest smaller. She felt unsafe, wasn't eating and stopped going out. Things spiralled. Philippa made a suicide attempt and the campus GP put her on antidepressants. 'I cut my hair, and it all became this project of de-feminising myself. It was working. I was getting less attention and that's what I wanted.'
Philippa was not in a good way. She began wearing breast binders and watching videos that suggested her feelings were down to gender dysphoria. A few weeks after her suicide attempt, she decided she was trans. The catalyst was YouTuber Aydian Dowling, a transgender activist with a beard who had changed body shape with testosterone, a mastectomy and gym work. Philippa was entranced. 'I was like, "if I can look like that, I'll do it!" She was a chubby woman who became a hot man with a beard, muscles and tattoos. She was so convincing.'
In March 2015, Philippa emailed her parents to tell them she was transitioning and wanted to be known as Caspar. She has blanked their specific reactions from her mind but describes the conversations at the time as 'difficult'. The next step was getting hold of testosterone. Taking advice from Reddit and Facebook trans forums, she saw a consultant psychiatrist and specialist gender clinician who runs a private clinic called GenderCare and works part-time in the NHS. The doctor recommended Philippa for hormone treatment. She was sent to the GenderCare consultant endocrinologist for a second opinion. He agreed. After two one-hour appointments costing around £250 each, Philippa was given a testosterone prescription. The first dose was injected in August 2015 at home, without enthusiasm, by her mum. The hormone accelerated Philippa's metabolism and altered her mindset. 'Before I was a scared girl. Suddenly I'm going on a walk because I'm not scared.'
On campus her social stock was rising. Philippa's male identity was celebrated. She joined Royal Holloway's LGBT+ Society, eventually becoming its president. 'I thought, this is the edge of progress. I'm at the forefront of female advancement. If women can do anything a man can do – how far can I take that? What if I could literally live as a man?'
Before Philippa had been on testosterone a full year, her doctor approved her for a double mastectomy, by remote appointment. Philippa met the £6,000 cost of surgery from savings. She shows me selfies she took in the recovery room. Tears aside, 'I thought I looked great', she says. 'But I was as high as a kite.'
Another selfie taken the same day in the family car catches her mother looking miserable in the background. Philippa became a self-taught tattoo artist. After graduating she settled in Lewisham, south London. She had been told the nearby Goldsmiths, University of London was the 'queerest' college in the capital, generating a ready source of students who might want to be tattooed by a cool-looking trans man. She met a woman and settled into a steady relationship. Philippa grew an Instagram following and became something of an influencer. 'There wasn't really anyone in the UK who looked better than me,' she says, unselfconsciously, 'and when I moved to London there wasn't anyone [on the trans scene] tattooing, so I got all the attention.'
Testosterone had boosted Philippa's height by two inches, she had a thickening beard and defined muscles. She looked like a small, attractive man. This influenced the women around her. 'I would meet people, then meet them later and they'd be trans. I'd ask, "What happened?" and they'd say, "Well, after meeting you...'''
Philippa calls this her 'biggest shame, my biggest regret'.
She briefly felt that she was living the dream. GenderCare had handed her on to the NHS, which supplied her with testosterone prescriptions; she cut off communication with her parents and thought she was having fun. But her income was reliant on a tight network. She received regular requests to donate towards funding mastectomies or facial feminisation procedures for trans people. 'When I surpassed 10,000 followers on Instagram, there was a shift. Suddenly I wasn't this young artist. It was, "Why aren't you helping younger members of the community?" I was like, "Hold on, I'm 23".'
Philippa says her position as poster boy for the trans community also led to questions about her commitment: she'd had a mastectomy and looked strikingly male, but could she truly be trans if she hadn't had 'bottom surgery'?
Philippa claims staff at her NHS clinic, the Laurels in Exeter, 'pestered' her to consider it. The surgery is not for the faint-hearted. One technique is called phalloplasty. It involves harvesting skin and fat from the belly, leg or arm, fashioning it into a phallus and attaching it to the genital area. The vagina can be sewn shut after a full hysterectomy or left open. The neophallus, as it is known, might look like a penis from a distance, but requires the implant of a silicone-gel prosthesis to become erect (a pump is sometimes secreted inside a neoscrotum, the latter being made from bits of genitalia). Sexual feeling is not guaranteed. Phalloplasty is irreversible, with potential complications including skin necrosis, loss of sensation and urinary incontinence. Still, Philippa considered it. She describes visiting a gender surgeon near London's Harley Street, who showed her pictures of the procedure. 'They were horrors beyond human comprehension', she says.
Philippa sees her transition as borne from a desire to feel safe and happy. As a small, blonde teenager, she felt surrounded and threatened by men whose sexual sensibilities had been shaped by internet porn. Changing identity and undergoing surgery as a subconscious flight response now seems drastic and Philippa sees herself as being groomed into 'a cult'. Her view hardened when she tried to leave. Philippa says she has already been hounded out of two cities by trans activists through a process known as 'dogpiling', or 'cancellation'. 'They find your workplace, message your colleagues, bombard social-media channels,' she says. 'They try to get every person around you to disassociate from you. Then they tell you to kill yourself.'
By 2019 Philippa felt disenfranchised by her lifestyle and the people around her. 'The ideology was changing. I would hear trans-identified women say they were male. I'd say, "This is a table of women. We all know that, right? We are lesbians. And there's nothing wrong with that."'
Philippa laughs at the pearl-clutching it provoked ('You can't say that!'). 'But because I looked more like a man than them and was higher status within the cult, they couldn't touch me.'
Then came the Covid lockdowns. Philippa says she was relieved she no longer had to act a part. 'I suddenly wasn't around trans people. I realised how exhausted I was the effect they were having on me.'
She began thinking about her lifestyle and the growing and vocal opposition to it. This seemed to come from groups of women dubbed Terfs (trans-exclusionary radical feminists), who believe you cannot change biological sex. On YouTube, Philippa found a video made by Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull, a controversial figure who describes herself as a women's-rights activist but not a feminist, and whose definition of woman is 'Adult Human Female'. Keen-Minshull's peroxide hair makes her instantly recognisable as a figure loathed by trans activists. 'They called her Mini Hitler,' says Philippa, 'the biggest Nazi in the UK, the anti-trans leader.'
Denouncing Keen-Minshull would have conferred status on Philippa. But as she watched the videos, she felt she was 'saying reasonable things: "men can't be women, you can't change sex, it's a cult".'
Philippa consumed all Keen-Minshull's videos and struggled to accept that the trans community's nemesis held views that matched her own. It started a period of introspection. Over summer 2021, Philippa began to taper her testosterone use and grew out her short hair. She still kept the beard and male pronouns. Struggling over her identity, Philippa decided she should meet Keen-Minshull, who runs a global movement called Let Women Speak (LWS). Any woman can take the mic at its rallies Keen-Minshull does not mind what views are aired, so long as they're lawful. In autumn 2022, Philippa attended an LWS event at Hyde Park. Electrified, she later joined them in the pub. Keen-Minshull told her, 'You need to get well'.
The experience galvanised her. The next month she posted on Instagram, noting the Cambridge Dictionary had expanded its definition of 'woman' to include 'an adult who lives and identifies as female though they may have been considered to have a different sex at birth'. Philippa said if biological men could be women, there was no point being transgender. Why try to change your sex or gender identity if you already are that identity by definition?
'I knew there'd be a backlash,' says Philippa.
There was. Her followers initially assumed her account had been hacked. Then, she says, accusations of transphobia began to fly. People were told not to read what she was posting. In the words of one post, it was 'dangerous'. She lost thousands of followers. As the abuse magnified, her tattooist work evaporated. Then things became more sinister. She says trans activists went after her girlfriend (who Philippa won't name), texting and calling her, harassing her constantly. 'They couldn't get to me,' says Philippa. 'So they went for everyone around me. They wanted maximal damage, mental and financial. They were prepared to do anything to get to me, and it worked, which is what I hate the most.'
The two have since split up. Philippa worried that if her address was discovered, she could be at risk of violence – she had received enough threatening social-media messages to feel unsafe. So, in 2023, she wiped her public Instagram account and moved to Norwich. She dropped the name Caspar for the more gender-neutral Robin and re-adopted female pronouns. She also shaved her beard which meant coming to terms with her masculine jawline, another effect of testosterone. After two years keeping a low profile, working minimum-wage jobs, Philippa rented space in a tattoo studio in the city centre. She felt the storm had blown over and wanted to earn proper money again, doing what she loved. She finished her first day happy, feeling she had turned a corner. But as she walked home, a fellow tattooist texted her. She had been sent screenshots of what Philippa had posted in 2022. The posts were being circulated around the Norwich LGBTQ+ scene. The dogpiling restarted. The studio owners told Philippa she was not welcome back. Angry, Philippa threw herself into the networks she had been building since meeting Keen-Minshull. She left behind the progressive thinking that told her she could change sex and now aligns herself with Keen-Minshull's politics. On X, she recently retweeted Keen-Minshull's statement, 'Islam is incompatible with women's rights', and caused a stir while being photographed for this piece, when she announced she would be attending Tommy Robinson's Unite The Kingdom rally in London. Even without the inflammatory public figures, the debate on women's rights and trans rights remains febrile. I ask Philippa what she thinks of last year's Supreme Court ruling that anchored the definition of 'woman' and 'man' in 'biological sex'.
Transitioning: the stats
0.5%
This is the percentage of the UK population thought to be trans or non-binary, around 262,000 people.
6,355
People under 25 were referred to NHS gender services in England in 2024-25.
2/3
Of young people being referred to gender clinics in England by 2018-19 were female.
0.5% to 13.1%
Is the estimated detransition rate.
'On paper it looks like a good thing,' she says. 'We needed to clarify the law. But it hasn't been implemented, so it was pointless. What's been eye-opening is seeing that the Supreme Court can say "this is the law" and major organisations say "we don't care".
That's quite alarming. We're in a lawless society on this. It wouldn't be a proper discussion about trans issues if we didn't touch on toilets. Philippa has little sympathy with trans people who face being challenged in public toilets. When she had a beard, she never used them. 'I knew what I looked like. If I walked into women's toilets looking like a man, they'd think a man had walked in. So I used gender-neutral or accessible single cubicles. Gender-neutral toilets are fine. But that's not where the activists want to go. They want to provoke a reaction.'
Philippa's relationship with her parents is 'much better than it used to be' and they are now talking, but her transition took 'a wrecking ball' to the family dynamic. 'It's not as big a tragedy as a disease or a death in the family, but at least you can make some sense of those. This was cultic brainwashing. Undoing language, changing names, getting the family to comply. The whole thing is asking people to lie.' Philippa and her parents have not had a meaningful discussion about what happened, 'so no one really knows what to do with it'.
Philippa is currently single and doesn't know if years of injecting testosterone has left her infertile. 'Finding that out would feel like a door of possibility closing,' she says. 'My periods came back a month after I stopped. But I don't know the state of my eggs. Did testosterone affect them? If I have kids, will they be OK?'
She tells me she had a short discussion ten years ago at GenderCare about freezing her eggs, but she told her doctor she had no intention of being a mother. Nothing more was said. Philippa's concern now is making a living. She says being a detransitioner can be lonely. 'Most want to disappear. They're ashamed. They see the backlash they'll face and think, "I'll quietly go over here."'
Philippa is re-establishing her online presence and hopes if ex friends and peers come after her again, she will be ready. She says she also wants to bring hope to people, especially women, who may have doubts about their transition. 'I want to show them light at the end of the tunnel. It'll be a difficult year or two, medically detransitioning, coming off hormones. These are powerful drugs. You'll probably lose friends, your life will feel wrecked for months. But it's worth it. It's like being given a whole new chance at life. Look how healthy I am. I'm not dramatically depressed or suicidal any more. Life is just fine. You don't realise how tense you are, thinking about how you're walking, talking. "Did that sound too feminine, am I standing right, am I swaying my hips?"
Now I just talk and walk. I'm no longer living a lie.'
This is exactly why pressure shouldn't be used to encourage people to transition. It's not the first time I've seen an article where somebody regrets even partial transitioning - these people need time and space before making a decision.