Soul of Adoption

General => General Discussion => The Great Debate => Topic started by: Topaz on Nov 17, 2026, 12:35 PM

Title: Why I'm NOT selfish for getting pregnant at 59, by Dr RENEE HOENDERKAMP ....
Post by: Topaz on Nov 17, 2026, 12:35 PM
https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16297785/NOT-selfish-pregnant-59-Dr-RENEE-HOENDERKAMP.html

Why I'm NOT selfish for getting pregnant at 59, by Dr RENEE HOENDERKAMP. My 66-year-old partner is delighted and I'm gone 12 weeks. This is our astonishing story

By DR RENEE HOENDERKAMP

Published: 01:00, 17 November 2026 | Updated: 06:57, 17 November 2026

The messages came in thick and fast, many of them as vitriolic as they were succinct. 'Revolting,' declared one. 'Disgusting,' pronounced another.  Others were more expansive, particularly those who felt that, as a doctor, I should have known better. 'I cannot believe someone who has medical training would think this is ok,' wrote one.

You might wonder what on earth I had done to provoke such public revulsion?

Suggested reusing surgical gloves?

Confessed to retrieving discarded food from hospital bins for my lunch?

In fact, my offence was simply to announce that I was pregnant.  Admittedly, there was one unusual detail. At 59, I am considerably older than the average expectant mother and already mother to a 37-year-old son and an eight-year-old daughter. Now, by the time my baby daughter arrives next year, I will have celebrated my 60th birthday.  Yet, while I anticipated surprise, even incredulity, I was unprepared for the sheer venom of the response when I shared my happy tidings on my GB News show The Saturday Five, which I co-host.  Apparently, bringing a much-wanted child into the world at my age is not merely unconventional but, according to some critics, profoundly selfish.  It is an accusation I find both hurtful and misguided and to understand why, you need to know something of my journey through motherhood, which began almost four decades ago and taught me that being biologically young enough to have a baby and emotionally ready to raise one are not necessarily the same thing.  I was just 21 when my eldest child, Calum, was born, arriving at five o'clock on New Year's morning, a mere three hours after I had left the pub where I had been seeing in the new year.  If ever there was proof that the female body is designed to have children in its early 20s, that was surely it. Unfortunately, the brain doesn't always keep pace one of nature's crueller ironies.  Calum hadn't been planned. I had been with his father for five years but we were both very young: he was 24. I had a good job in publishing, though, and a decent income and saw no reason why I shouldn't become a mother. What I hadn't appreciated was the extraordinary emotional commitment motherhood demands.  I separated from Calum's father shortly after his birth and returned to full-time work when he was just 28 days old, leaving home at seven in the morning and frequently not returning until eight at night.  I provided a nanny, nursery care and a comfortable home, reassuring myself that these were the ingredients of a happy childhood.  But one vital ingredient was missing: me. Calum now a wonderful young man to whom I am very close grew into a rather cross, hyperactive little boy who was constantly getting into trouble at school. Looking back, I believe much of that behaviour was a desperate attempt to attract my attention.  I didn't understand that then. Indeed, it took the arrival of my second child, Alice, almost three decades later, to appreciate quite how differently motherhood could be experienced.  But back then, I spent much of my 30s concentrating on my career. I subsequently married an older man and, although he was keen for children, throughout our 17-year marriage I never felt ready to embark on motherhood again.  Then, after the breakdown of that marriage, I decided, aged 39, to retrain as a doctor, via which process I met Colin, a surgeon seven years my senior. Romance blossomed when, aged 43, I began my first medical job at the Royal London Hospital.  A father of five, Colin had also experienced a failed marriage, and with six children between us, adding to our family was hardly an immediate priority.  But as my 40s progressed, something shifted. I felt settled, my career was established and the ticking of my biological clock began to make itself heard.  Even so, we decided not to force the issue. Instead, I stopped using contraception and took the view that if Mother Nature wanted to bless us with a child, she would.  And, remarkably, at 50, I discovered I was pregnant naturally, and contrary to the alarmist headlines which sometimes make later-life motherhood sound like a hazardous expedition to Mars, my pregnancy was wonderfully straightforward.  Initially referred to a high-risk clinic because of my age, I was quickly discharged after a doctor reassured me I was in better condition than many of the 30-year-olds sent his way.  I continued running 5km three times a week and worked until almost the last minute, my one concession to age at Colin's urging to opt for an elective caesarean.  As a consequence, Alice arrived at 37 weeks and four days, weighing a petite 2.65kg (5lb 13oz). We were home within 18 hours, and three days later I was trotting to the shops.  From the outset, Alice was an absolute joy: an enchanting, engaging little girl whose arrival transformed our lives, and continues to do so. Watching her grow has brought home the enormous difference between the mother I was at 21 and the mother I became at 50.  This time, I could give my daughter something I hadn't been able to offer Calum: my time.  Colin and I were financially secure and able to organise our working lives around her. One of us has been there for every school drop-off, every collection, every breakfast and bedtime.  Of course, I know plenty of young mothers combine demanding careers with raising wonderfully happy children. I am not suggesting age alone makes anyone a better parent. But my experience has convinced me that emotional maturity, patience and the ability to be present are infinitely more important than society sometimes acknowledges.  Nonetheless, with seven children between us, and Colin approaching his 60th birthday, you might imagine we considered our family complete.  Certainly, Colin did. I, however, wasn't quite so sure. As Alice grew, I became increasingly reluctant to accept that this extraordinary chapter of my life was over. Her frequent and heartfelt requests for a sibling only strengthened that feeling.  Fortunately, back in my 30s I had decided to freeze my eggs, recognising that although I felt little appetite for another baby then, my future self might feel differently.  As I marched through my 50s those frozen eggs offered the possibility of another child albeit with some formidable obstacles. The NHS has strict age criteria for state-funded IVF, while most private British clinics are reluctant to treat women beyond their mid-50s.  The Covid pandemic further complicated matters, and when we emerged it became clear that my best opportunity lay abroad. Eventually, after a great deal of intensive research, I found a clinic in Poland willing to consider treating me, provided I passed its assessment deeming me healthy enough to carry a pregnancy.  That meant extensive investigations, including cardiac and abdominal scans and breast examinations.  Happily, I passed with flying colours. Using my frozen eggs and Colin's sperm, we created embryos that were then tested for chromosomal abnormalities. Three were considered suitable for transfer and last July, I underwent my first embryo transfer.  What followed was an emotional rollercoaster for which even my medical training could not prepare me and a lonely journey since. Apart from family and a handful of trusted friends, almost nobody knew what we were attempting.  The first transfer failed, and so did the second, each negative pregnancy test bringing its own devastation. However pragmatic you try to be, it is impossible not to nurture hope, or prevent that hope crashing down when another attempt fails.  I began wondering whether I was asking too much of fate, and certainly, by the time I returned for another transfer in September, my optimism was wearing thin.  I had suffered shingles the previous month, and was battling a stonking cold. Sitting in the clinic waiting room, feeling thoroughly below par, I remember thinking this probably wasn't going to work.  But five days later, there it was: the faintest line on a pregnancy test, a line that only grew stronger when I tested the following day, and the next.  There was no mistaking it: I was pregnant. My elation was enormous, swiftly accompanied by fear.  Anyone who has undergone IVF knows how difficult it can be to trust good news. There are early losses and countless things that can go wrong.  A small bleed did nothing to settle my nerves, nor did dealing with the miscarriages experienced by some of my female patients, each one heartbreaking and a painful reminder that pregnancy offers no guarantees, whatever your age.  Yet here I am today, 12 weeks pregnant with a baby girl who is thriving. After weeks of extraordinary fatigue, I am finally beginning to feel myself again.  Alice is beside herself with joy and has already christened her baby sister 'Splodge'.  My 83-year-old mother is equally delighted. Becoming a grandmother to Alice in her 70s gave her a wonderful new lease of life, and their affectionate close relationship is one of the great joys of my life.  Calum, who now has a child of his own around Alice's age, has taken it in his stride too, jokingly describing the news as 'insane' before adding that if it makes us happy, that's all that matters.  Which brings me back to the less generous reaction from complete strangers. After reading some of the comments on Sunday night, I became so angry that I eventually had to step away from the internet.  Much of the criticism centres on the accusation that I am selfish. Many people have suggested I am having this baby 'for me'. Well, isn't that true of almost every woman who deliberately sets out to become a mother?

We don't ordinarily demand that women in their 20s or 30s justify their desire for children as an act of altruism.  Why should that desire suddenly become morally suspect simply because a woman is older?

In my case, Alice has also longed for a sibling closer to her own age, and giving her that relationship is part of what motivated me.  Of course, I understand the central objection: that I may not live long enough to see this child grow into adulthood.  It is a legitimate concern, and one I have considered carefully. I cannot promise I will be alive when my daughter turns 30, or even 20. But who can?

Yes, I have undoubtedly got fewer years ahead than behind me but as a doctor, I see people considerably younger than me whose health is far more precarious. Illness and tragedy do not politely wait until someone reaches pensionable age.  Colin, for his part, has enjoyed fatherhood immensely as an older man, believing he has more time and patience to give.  That doesn't mean age is irrelevant. But nor do I believe the possibility of an earlier bereavement automatically outweighs the prospect of a happy, secure and deeply loved childhood. My children have a stable home, parents who adore them, financial security and a loving extended family.  Alice tells me frequently that she loves her life. Do people think that life should not exist because I had her in my 50s?

And there is something else about the criticism that strikes me as revealing: almost nobody seems interested in the fact that Colin is 66. Older fatherhood has long been treated as an eccentricity, sometimes even an achievement. Mick Jagger and Bernie Ecclestone have both become fathers at ages considerably beyond those at which women are routinely told to abandon the idea.  Yet when a woman chooses to have a baby at 59, the reaction borders on moral outrage.  Of course, there are biological differences between older mothers and fathers. But when criticism moves beyond medical risk into accusations of selfishness, why does judgment fall so disproportionately on women?

There is also a curious contradiction in our attitude towards medical science. We celebrate advances that allow people to live longer, overcome illness and enjoy possibilities denied to previous generations. Yet when fertility treatment enables an older woman to have another child, some regard it as an unacceptable interference with nature.  I don't believe everything science makes possible should automatically be done. Nor am I suggesting motherhood at 59 is right for every woman, or even most women. What I ask is that people resist reducing an intensely personal decision to a single, supposedly damning number.  I know I will be an unusually old mother. I know there may be challenges ahead, and things I cannot control. At 21, I had youth on my side, but far less understanding of what motherhood required of me.  Nearly four decades later, while I have fewer years ahead of me, I also have the wisdom, patience and freedom to make the most of every moment.  My new daughter will arrive into a family where she is desperately wanted, surrounded by people who already love her. In a world where much of our news is cause for enormous gloom, isn't that something to celebrate?