I was all set to adopt beautiful little Tommy before I made this discovery....

Started by Mumof1, Sep 09, 2025, 06:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mumof1

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-15076531/adopted-child-rejected-FASD-child-guilt.html#newcomment

I was all set to adopt beautiful little Tommy before I made this discovery. I had to reject him and now I'm haunted by guilt. But when you hear my story, you'll understand why

By SUSAN PHILLIPS

Published: 17:20, 8 September 2025 | Updated: 17:20, 8 September 2025

Last weekend I could have sworn I saw the teenage boy who would, had things worked out differently, have been my adopted son.  We briefly locked eyes as I put my groceries through the till at the supermarket where he was working.  And that fleeting connection was enough to make my heart drop with a sickening thud as I silently wondered, is it you?

For years, I've been tormented with thoughts of what might have been, convincing myself that random children might be the beautiful toddler my husband Mike and I were on the brink of adopting.  At the 11th hour we withdrew from the process after disturbing information about Tommy came to light.  But I remain haunted by the idea that we let that little boy down. Reminding myself that we were effectively lied to by our social worker doesn't assuage my guilt.  And so, seeing the name 'Tom' on this youngster's ID badge, then recognising he had the same jet-black hair, narrow lips and hazel-coloured eyes as the toddler whose photograph I keep tucked away inside my jewellery box, brought everything flooding back.  It was our biological daughter Chloe who'd tipped the balance when we first began considering adoption.  Conceived through IVF, she was the centre of our world and desperate for a sibling.  But I'd suffered two miscarriages before her, and another after and all my pregnancies had been through private IVF treatment. We couldn't afford any more – emotionally or financially.  But we felt we had plenty of love to give another child, and didn't care whether they carried our genes.  We weren't naive, and went into the adoption process fully aware it doesn't inevitably provide the fairytale ending prospective parents want.  After all, these are children who have been either taken away from, or rejected by, their birth families, and that almost always has a profound impact on their emotional development.  Recent research by the charity Adoption UK found that around half of families with adopted children aged 13 to 25 say they are at 'crisis point' or facing severe challenges as they deal with the aftermath of their son or daughter's trauma.  More than half (58 per cent) of adopted young adults accessed or attempted to access mental health services last year. The charity also found that 23 per cent of adopted 16 to 25-year-olds are not in education, employment or training, which is nearly double the UK average.  While there's no official data on how many adoptions break down, Adoption UK believes that happens in between 3 and 9 per cent of cases.  And if the statistics don't remove your rose-tinted glasses, then the adoption process will.  It took two years before we were finally approved to adopt a baby aged from nought to three, during which we were interrogated about our lifestyle and intentions.  Our parents and siblings were all interviewed to establish what kind of people we were.  Even Chloe's headmaster got asked for his opinion on us as parents.  We understood, of course, that anyone adopting a child needs to be rigorously assessed but some of the requirements seemed unreasonable.  Early on, our social worker Karen bluntly declared that if we had sex we must use contraception every time, as though we were a couple of teenagers, not two 42-year-olds who'd gone through the hell of fertility treatment and several miscarriages.  Yet we were too scared of the power she had over us she would hold huge sway with the adoption panel to challenge her, even though it seemed intrusive.  She even questioned my ability to reconcile being a good parent with the fact I worked full time as a public relations consultant, even though I was already doing exactly that with Chloe. Working freelance meant I had considerable say over my hours, as long as I got the job done. I'd already told my clients I would be taking six months of adoption leave. Mike also worked part time, yet she didn't raise the same concern with him.  We also had to consider what sort of child we might be willing to adopt.  The 'What Will You Take?' list we were given made stark reading: would we take a child who was the product of rape?

Or incest?

Or whose mother was addicted to drugs?

Could we parent someone with serious health problems or developmental delays?

It felt horrible, considering children in such a way.  But we also had to be realistic about adopting a child whose needs we felt confident we could meet.  In particular, we had to think of Chloe and the impact a sibling with serious developmental or psychological problems would have on her.  So we said 'no' to them all, including, crucially, the child of an alcoholic, because of the enormous risk of them developing FASD – child foetal alcohol syndrome.  Caused by exposure to alcohol in the womb, which can harm brain cells and damage the nervous system, FASD is a serious neurodevelopmental condition that creates lifelong cognitive, emotional and behavioural challenges, the severity of which only becomes apparent over time.  Children with FASD often have abnormal facial features, such as a smooth ridge between the nose and upper lip, and are below average height.  They can have heart, kidney and bone problems plus issues with their vision and hearing. That's on top of learning difficulties, potentially serious behavioural issues and problems with their memory, co-ordination and speech.  It was on our radar because, around the time we applied, we spoke to friends of friends who'd adopted after several failed rounds of IVF.  Their daughter had FASD, which they knew about from the start.  They told us they had naively believed that bucket loads of love would be enough, but the reality had proved far harder than they'd ever imagined.  They loved their daughter, but described her as a ticking bomb of emotional and developmental problems. She couldn't cope with mainstream school, had various health problems and regularly had meltdowns so extreme they'd last more than an hour.  'We get on top of one problem, and another surfaces,' the wife told us. 'We don't feel like a couple anymore. We're now just two people who work together to raise a child who will always need looking after. If we had our time over, we wouldn't have adopted her.'

We sent the form in feeling guilty but also relieved we'd been honest.  Still, Karen phoned me in exasperation.  'You're being too picky,' she said. 'You're not Mary Poppins; you're not going to float home with a little bundle who was the result of two nice teenagers getting carried away.'

But we stood firm, even though we knew it would reduce our chances of a match.  So we were surprised when four months later Karen called and said she had a lovely little boy she thought would be a perfect match Tommy.  We met the following week to discuss next steps. Seeing his picture was a powerful moment.  Mike and I wept, first as we looked at his little face, and then again when as we read the file that told us about his difficult start in life.  We learned that Tommy had been put on the 'at risk' register as soon as social services knew his birth mother was pregnant: his two older siblings had been taken into care as toddlers due to neglect. She had named him Tommy before he was removed soon after birth.  There was nothing in the paperwork to suggest we wouldn't be able to meet Tommy's needs so we spent the next couple of months excitedly preparing to finally become a family of four.  Finally, it was just two days until we were due to meet Tommy for the first time. Over subsequent days, we'd have spent more time with him, eventually having him on our own before ultimately taking him home.  But everything changed when I received a devastating phone call.  It was from Tommy's foster mother, Dawn, who wanted to share her very serious concerns that he might have FASD.  She'd correctly sensed that our social worker, Karen, had kept Mike and me in the dark.  I'd even asked Karen directly if he'd been put at risk. She said his mother 'wasn't known to be a drinker', before changing the subject.

Symptoms of FASD can take years to surface. For some children, their facial features a large head, with small eyes and thin lips can be an early indicator, but it's not something you'd necessarily notice in a photograph.  But Dawn explained how Tommy's head was measuring extremely large, and his body too short according to his growth charts.  'He's a sweet little boy,' she added. 'But he doesn't play much and isn't particularly engaged with the world.  He isn't thriving, whatever your social worker might be telling you. I also think I can see signs of it in his face.'

She said she'd raised her concerns with the adoption team several weeks ago and that the paediatrician attached to social services had examined him several times since then.  And yet, none of this had been shared with us.  Dawn had recently visited us at home, along with Karen, as part of the preparations for Tommy coming to live with us.  'I sensed at that meeting you didn't realise what you could be letting yourselves in for,' she said.

She was right.  Up to that point we'd been assured Tommy was happy, healthy and, yes, thriving. At that recent meeting, all Karen had talked about was his sleeping patterns, his favourite foods and how we felt.  'Thrilled,' was the simple answer.

Chloe, then aged seven, had a photograph of him on her bedside table in a frame that said: 'I Love My Brother'.

Meanwhile, Mike and I had been astonished by the strong feelings we were already developing towards him, just as we had with Chloe before she was born.  'I think social services are just hoping for the best,' Dawn added. 'With these children, it's often a case of seeing how they turn out.  Tommy might be the best thing that ever happens to you. But equally, caring for him might take over your whole life, and possibly ruin it. You need to decide whether that's a gamble you're prepared to take.'

We already knew it wasn't. As much as Mike and I longed for another baby, it stated on our file that we wouldn't take on a child with complex needs.  We felt we weren't selfless enough for that. And we weren't prepared to turn Chloe's life upside down.  After a sleepless night, we called Karen, praying she'd somehow put our minds at rest.  Instead, she blamed the foster mother, who she said had broken the rules in contacting us.  Finally, she conceded that yes, the paediatrician had said Tommy was displaying some indicators of FASD, and yes, his mother did have a history of heavy drinking.  But Karen added that none of her other children had FASD, and so they were confident she hadn't drunk alcohol during the pregnancy.  'There's nothing concrete at this stage to say he has this condition at all,' she added.

I felt instantly furious.  'In other words, you were prepared to gamble with our lives, just to get that little boy off your hands,' I snapped back at her, my voice raised.

'Does this mean you're not taking him?' Karen asked.

Mike and I looked at each other. He shook his head, I shook mine, then we both started crying as I told her: 'I'm sorry Karen, but no, we can't.'

She immediately erupted: 'You're just middle-class cherry pickers. I don't know how you can live with yourselves.'

Her words cut like a knife, as I abruptly ended the call.  I think they always will, because even though I knew the adoption team was the ultimate architect of this awful situation, I also felt she had a point.  We did only want a certain type of child.  But we had never lied about this. It was the social workers who had been less than honest.  Naively, we presumed everything we'd said would be respected. It was now obvious to us that it hadn't.  'I wanted to make sure you knew the truth before you started to bond with him,' Dawn had told us.

Even so, we felt like we'd lost a child.  Mike and I both grieved for the little boy who was so nearly ours.  We wept on and off for weeks. And made the decision then that the trust had been broken, and withdrew from the adoption process.  We felt we'd let down Chloe, too.  Thankfully, kids are resilient. She had a little cry, but then went out to play in the garden with Mike, and never mentioned Tommy again. We haven't ever raised it with her. Even now, as an adult herself, she hasn't brought it up.  I'm glad Chloe was able to forget about him so quickly. Even 15 years on that's something I've never been able to do.  I know, deep down, the chances of the boy I saw last weekend being Tommy are incredibly slim. But I really want to believe it could have been.  The alternative that he ended up broken by the care system, because after we backed out of adopting him, no one else wanted him either – is too painful to contemplate.

    *Susan Phillips is a pseudonym. All names and identifying details have been changed.