Ruth grew up believing her mum died in a freak accident. At 16, she ....

Started by Admin, Feb 10, 2025, 05:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Admin

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14378439/Ruth-mum-died-freak-accident-discovered-truth.html

Ruth grew up believing her mum died in a freak accident. At 16, she discovered the horrifying truth and then VANISHED. Thirty years on, her best friend asks: What WAS in the notes left at the spot where she was last seen?

By KATHRYN KNIGHT

Published: 01:31, 10 February 2025 | Updated: 13:35, 10 February 2025

During one of the last conversations Catherine Mair had with her friend Ruth Wilson, the teenager made a plea.  At just 17, Catherine was leaving home, moving north from Surrey to Sheffield, and Ruth desperately wanted to join her.  'She asked if she could come with me,' Catherine recalls. 'But at that point I knew I would need some time to get myself sorted. I promised that, once I was settled, I would let her know and she could come.'

Ruth never got the opportunity. Within a couple of weeks of that anguished request, the 16-year-old schoolgirl had vanished from her home in the Surrey village of Betchworth.  She was last seen on a cold, wet, late November afternoon in 1995 by a taxi driver who had just dropped her off at Box Hill, a famous beauty spot nearby.  The taxi driver later reported that Ruth was ill-clad for the wet weather, wearing no coat over her red sweater and black velvet trousers. She stayed rooted to the spot as he drove away.  There has been no official trace of Ruth who would have turned 46 at the end of last month in the nearly 30 years since. To all intents and purposes, she vanished into thin air.  It places the teenager in the poignant canon of the disappeared, trailing a number of troubling questions in her wake chief among them being what, exactly, was going through her mind when she booked a taxi from Dorking railway station to take her to dark and isolated woodland that stormy Monday afternoon?

Catherine believes she knows, although like so many of those who knew Ruth and remain haunted by her disappearance she remains baffled as to what exactly may have happened to her.  'I know she was unhappy at home,' says Catherine, now a 46-year-old mother and carer. 'Obviously that is not entirely unusual for teenage girls, but her mind was in turmoil, and she really wanted to get away.'

Ruth and Catherine had become close while doing their A-levels at The Ashcombe School in Dorking, where Ruth was studying biology and chemistry and thinking of reading archaeology at university.  'We knew each other before, but the dynamics changed when we got much closer in sixth form,' says Catherine. 'She was very shy and quiet all the way through school, certainly not one of the popular ones. But I realised she was bright and interesting and funny.'

On the surface, at least, Ruth seemed to have everything going for her.  The eldest daughter of Ian, a well-liked schoolteacher and parish councillor, and his wife Nesta, she grew up alongside her younger sister Jenny in a picturesque 17th-century cottage, did well at school and had plenty of hobbies.  She sang in a local choir, played electric guitar and was a bellringer at the local church.  Yet her life had already been shaped by tragedy. On December 10, 1982, when Ruth was three and Jenny less than a year old, their mother died at the age of 33, after apparently tripping at the top of the stairs and breaking her neck in a freak accident at home.  That, at least, was what Ruth was told by her father and Karen Bowerman, the deputy head teacher of a primary school, whom Ian married a year after the death of his wife.  'Sadly, Ruth seemed convinced she was responsible,' says Catherine. 'She believed it was one of her toys that her mum had tripped over.'

This notion was reinforced by another friend of Ruth's, who asked not to be identified, but told the Mail that 'she definitely believed, or had persuaded herself, that it was one of her toys that had caused her mother's accident'.

In the months before she went missing, Ruth became determined to find out more. In early October 1995, she travelled to London to visit the public records office where details of births, marriages and deaths were stored.  She went with her boyfriend Will Kennedy to get a copy of her mother's death certificate. What she found stunned her: Nesta's death was not an accident, but a suicide.  She had hanged herself and was later declared dead in hospital.  It is, of course, entirely understandable that her father would want to shield his young children from this horrifying truth. Yet Ruth became consumed by the revelation, says Catherine.  'Obviously it's crazy to find out that something you've been told your entire life isn't true, whatever the reasons,' she adds. 'Understandably it left a lot of questions for her why her mother, with two young babies, would take her life just weeks before Christmas.  Ruth was distressed and confused and started asking some dark questions. She became fixated on getting to the heart of exactly what had happened.'

Today, Catherine feels a sense of regret that she did not spend more time trying to unravel her friend's complex emotions, but at the time she had her own problems. Also unhappy in Surrey, she had made the bold decision to leave home and start a new life nearly 200 miles away in Sheffield.  'I'd visited the city before and had a boyfriend who lived there, so I was able to stay with him at first,' she recalls.

The decision worked out: Catherine took her A-levels there and eventually settled in Sheffield, where she now lives with her wife and children, three of whom are fostered and one of whom is adopted. She also has an older daughter, Imogen, who has married and left home.  Yet she has never forgotten her old friend. 'I've thought about her a lot over the years,' she says. 'Particularly now I have a daughter who is the same age as Ruth was when she went missing. It brings it all back.'

Certainly, it seems the weeks leading up to Ruth's disappearance were fraught.  In a 2018 documentary Vanished: The Surrey Schoolgirl, made for YouTube's Real Stories channel by Surrey-based journalist Martin Bright, a school friend of Ruth's called Ben Anderton claims Ruth ran away from home a month before her disappearance and 'hid out' at his house in Betchworth. 'She wasn't happy at home and wanted to escape,' Ben said.

Catherine, too, recalls her friend repeatedly asking to stay over rather than return home.  'I remember once she didn't want to tell her dad where she was, and my mum said she could only stay if she called him. She was saying over and over again, "I don't want him to know".  On that occasion, she called her dad and he did persuade her to go home.'

Not long after that, Ruth, along with other school friends, went to a sleepover at Catherine's on November 11 to mark her 17th birthday the previous day.  'She was in good spirits that night,' remembers Catherine.

Of course, neither Catherine, nor any of her other friends, could know what would happen next: that just over two weeks later and ten days after Catherine had left Surrey for Sheffield Ruth would vanish.  The weekend before her disappearance, Ruth worked at the music shop where she had a Saturday job before going out for a meal with Will by this time her ex-boyfriend, although they remained friends and another pal, Neil Phillipson.  Both boys later stated Ruth paid for the meal, saying it was 'something to remember her by'.

The following day, Ruth went to bellringing practice before heading to a youth club in Dorking. Afterwards she went to Will's home for supper, before returning to her own home.  Monday dawned, cold and miserable. Ruth's father had an Ofsted inspection and left home in a rush something he later said has always haunted him. Karen, too, had to leave early. Ruth normally got the school bus with her sister, but it seems she had no intention of going to school that day.  She told Jenny that she would head in later, declined the offer of a lift from Will, who passed by her home, and instead ordered a taxi to Dorking Library, where she spent a few hours.  She also called in to a local florist's called Thistles, where she ordered a bouquet of flowers for her stepmother, leaving instructions that they were to be delivered in two days' time and no sooner. There was no card attached.  Next, she walked to Dorking railway station and ordered a taxi to drop her near the entrance to a bridleway, close to a pub at the top of Box Hill called the Hand In Hand.  It was 4.30pm, getting dark, and raining. The taxi driver never publicly named told detectives his last sighting of Ruth in his rear view mirror showed her standing still in the rain. The driver observed that this was unusual, as people tend to walk away after being dropped off.  Later that night, as Ruth had not come home, Ian and Karen reported her missing.  Surrey Police began a wide-ranging search across 1,000 acres of parkland, using dog teams, heat-seeking equipment and a helicopter.  'I always thought it was odd that they launched such a huge search so quickly,' says Catherine. 'Teenagers fail to come home all the time. It made me wonder what they thought they knew.'

Two days later, the flowers arrived for her stepmother. Catherine is in no doubt they were not a gesture of goodwill. 'She was making a point, whatever that point was,' she insists.

Although never confirmed by Surrey Police, on December 1, 1995, The Times reported that officers had found three notes hidden in a bush on Box Hill: one each to her father and stepmother, and one to a friend. The contents have never been revealed.

Nearby were said to be an empty packet of paracetamol tablets and a bottle of vermouth. But there were no other belongings at all, and no sign of the blue duffel bag Ruth had been carrying when she took the taxi.  Catherine, by now in Sheffield, learned the news of her friend's disappearance from a telephone call home to her mother.  'Obviously it was horrible,' she says. 'At the same time the awful reality was that there wasn't really much I could do. We didn't have mobile phones in those days, we didn't have social media.  Today we would have so much more information we'd know when someone's phone was switched off, we'd have all this information online. But back then people were working in the dark.'

She considered reaching out to Ruth's parents, but decided against it, assuming that they would make contact should they wish to.  'They never have,' she says. 'They have never once got in touch with me, or my mother, despite the fact that Ruth stayed at my home frequently in the time before she left.  I am sure they have their reasons, but both mum and I have always thought it odd wouldn't it be one of the first things you would do?'

Several days after their daughter's disappearance, the Wilsons appeared on ITV breakfast programme This Morning appealing for her return and, in 2006, Ian penned an open letter to his missing daughter for the Mail, in which he wrote of his ongoing grief.  'We still have the presents we bought you for Christmas in 1995,' he said. 'They're safe in a drawer waiting for you to come back, though I expect your tastes have changed so much you'd probably laugh at the music and clothes.'

Since then, however, the family, including Ruth's sister Jenny, have chosen to avoid publicity.  No doubt they, too, are consumed by the questions that continue to grip Ruth's friends, many of whom convene regularly on a Facebook group dedicated to keeping her memory alive.  They try, even after all these years, to get to the bottom of what happened to the schoolgirl.  Among the continued puzzles is why, if Ruth took her own life, has her body never been found?

What was the purpose of the flowers to her stepmother, sent at such a specific time?

And is there any truth to an odd sighting on CCTV, a year to the day after she vanished, which showed a distressed girl resembling Ruth at a Dorking newsagent asking for local newspapers?

While the footage is grainy, the Wilsons who had been told that if Ruth had died on Box Hill her body would have been found by now later said they believed the footage was of the teenager.  'We want to tell her, "We love you so much. Just get in contact Ruthie, let us know where you are",' Karen Wilson told a journalist in the wake of the footage's release.

Catherine, though, refuses to believe it could be Ruth. 'It doesn't make sense if you wanted to get away, then why come back to the area you were trying to get away from on the anniversary?' she asks.

'That's before you get to whether it is plausible that a 16-year-old girl managed to start a new life under the radar for a year and then just choose to revisit the place she had left behind. Her bank account was never touched.'

Like many of those still haunted by Ruth's disappearance, Catherine doesn't know what to think.  'I find it hard to believe she took her own life but also that she managed to start a new life,' she says. 'What I do know is that I would love nothing more than for Ruth to just suddenly walk back into our lives.'

In a statement, Surrey Police says it 'continues to keep an open mind about what is behind Ruth's disappearance' and 'at this time there is no further evidence to support any one particular line of inquiry about what has happened to Ruth'.

It added that Ruth's case remains a missing person inquiry.